{ "scope": "One-day airport consistency comparison; no local physical validation or concentration prediction.", "protocol": { "createdUTC": "2026-09-11T15:09:02.507353+00:00", "previousGoalTurnClassification": "progress: three completed expanded cases, source/grid verification, public community audit and verified deployment inspected. No live processes carried forward.", "purpose": "Evaluate whether diagnostic terrain processing and added computational support change consistency with available observed surface wind. All-community objective retained; one in-domain station does not validate the airshed.", "selection": "Same complete June1 fixed-PST run, containing station cell selected geometrically and all six saved cases retained. Model/observation error values not calculated before this protocol.", "stationCoverage": [ { "key": "airport", "reference": { "name": "Squamish Airport", "longitude": -123.16119444444445, "latitude": 49.783208333333334, "station_id": 336, "climate_identifier": "10476F0", "coordinate_source": { "path": "work/hourly_2025_raw.json", "sha256": "7dce82761cef7f9584ecb329fb8f19fa971fc591214bc5d3844dedd8bf57fcb2", "selection": "features[0].geometry.coordinates and matching latitude/longitude metadata properties" }, "point_role": "Retained ECCC station location only; no wind/time values processed and no sensor heights inferred." }, "utmM": [ 488395.80373672384, 5514539.731766353 ], "expandedRowSouth0": 144, "expandedColumnWest0": 121, "insideExpandedDomain": true, "southBoundarySignedDistanceM": 28939.73176635336, "observationFile": "work/bc-wrf-access/june-2023-eccc/airport-2023-06-native.json", "observationSha256": "75c1c04b33bc037089bcea4647cf46d5f693f6e5296cf8e23e25261fad529e94", "modelCellCentreUTMm": [ 488300, 5514500 ], "cellCentreOffsetM": 103.71580992215952 }, { "key": "pam-rocks", "reference": { "name": "Pam Rocks", "longitude": -123.29945277777777, "latitude": 49.48778027777778, "station_id": 6817, "climate_identifier": "10459NN", "coordinate_source": { "path": "work/annual-winds/pam-rocks-2025-original.json", "sha256": "e5b546620e6bb66d68f0bcf7a3f596bfabefdea01a2b8837c9f304f4df4e3874", "selection": "features[0].geometry.coordinates and matching latitude/longitude metadata properties" }, "point_role": "Retained ECCC station location only; no wind/time values processed and no sensor heights inferred." }, "utmM": [ 478311.96536569763, 5481725.39069357 ], "expandedRowSouth0": -20, "expandedColumnWest0": 71, "insideExpandedDomain": false, "southBoundarySignedDistanceM": -3874.609306430444, "observationFile": "work/bc-wrf-access/june-2023-eccc/pam-rocks-2023-06-native.json", "observationSha256": "1f53cf17e6eb5343a4c8f54f11ddf3cb5b7d7dab76bc9673c55efcff505d31b6" } ], "comparisonStation": "airport", "cases": [ { "id": "original/wrf-interpolation", "domain": "original", "physicalCase": "wrf-interpolation", "nx": 101, "ny": 101, "nz": 10, "originM": [ 474000, 5495600 ], "spacingM": 200, "rowSouth0": 94, "columnWest0": 71, "runDirectory": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/wrf-interpolation", "controlSha256": "4c62e1608cc0939de90015a3e70dc57f91b7e92c255a80e453a1ea33155e1d24", "outputSha256": "e761091d59087964939a045c197a318d2274d017f31b042902a79d0ef485c205" }, { "id": "original/terrain-5km", "domain": "original", "physicalCase": "terrain-5km", "nx": 101, "ny": 101, "nz": 10, "originM": [ 474000, 5495600 ], "spacingM": 200, "rowSouth0": 94, "columnWest0": 71, "runDirectory": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/terrain-5km", "controlSha256": "71f02d98eaadcda0d66008201c618905c7f4af72aa93f26d61201bea395b0e1b", "outputSha256": "6f5a5890874be484c1f7f11d81534d42836257d44ddb743a9fa8013dc939f0fc" }, { "id": "original/terrain-10km", "domain": "original", "physicalCase": "terrain-10km", "nx": 101, "ny": 101, "nz": 10, "originM": [ 474000, 5495600 ], "spacingM": 200, "rowSouth0": 94, "columnWest0": 71, "runDirectory": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/terrain-10km", "controlSha256": "368595cb54b48987aa12288a39a1dcb5d7bcd55a7376cf08ce677d7dbfc65b65", "outputSha256": "f872e3c08e45fca3fafcaa32f73398e0a40d8dd5e6b6343eb89106492761fc09" }, { "id": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "domain": "expanded", "physicalCase": "wrf-interpolation", "nx": 201, "ny": 201, "nz": 10, "originM": [ 464000, 5485600 ], "spacingM": 200, "rowSouth0": 144, "columnWest0": 121, "runDirectory": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/wrf-interpolation", "controlSha256": "be5cff439162ad3068807bb5297ff24f07b6dd0da87a7b1cbc96d5dbc1e97930", "outputSha256": "87fa4e6c19c1a663efe7211a47fd60bd54aff9bf3d6f38ccd62ba7d4ec59eadc" }, { "id": "expanded/terrain-5km", "domain": "expanded", "physicalCase": "terrain-5km", "nx": 201, "ny": 201, "nz": 10, "originM": [ 464000, 5485600 ], "spacingM": 200, "rowSouth0": 144, "columnWest0": 121, "runDirectory": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/terrain-5km", "controlSha256": "0e614895b605fe38e7817ae0173c33571e5e38244e58497a8fe6e878c7f5330e", "outputSha256": "a37c6e4d1de051b0ec8a6f2633def1ee38682b9514bb20941f834c897291e2bb" }, { "id": "expanded/terrain-10km", "domain": "expanded", "physicalCase": "terrain-10km", "nx": 201, "ny": 201, "nz": 10, "originM": [ 464000, 5485600 ], "spacingM": 200, "rowSouth0": 144, "columnWest0": 121, "runDirectory": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/terrain-10km", "controlSha256": "fb4b7bb338b37d0fbc9dadee911e54d4fbf28f44624d316d051afac42901af90", "outputSha256": "8bc1b4c5b5da07d6f95bbcb0c7fc5bda08e74670b4f727e398967bdf46b32002" } ], "timeOperator": { "intervalUTC": "June1 2023 08:00 through June2 08:00", "observationTimestampUTC": "June1 09:00 through June2 08:00 inclusive,24labels", "basis": "Source review RDMM5 interpolates native wind at ndathre/nsece; saved records encode same hour label with endseconds3600. Normalize timestamps.", "meaning": "Diagnostic field for interval, driven by endpoint native wind state; slope/thermal routines also use midpoint solar angle/history. Neither a guaranteed instantaneous field nor an hourly mean.", "comparisonLimit": "ECCC near-hour reports have unresolved station-specific sampling-window/history. Timestamp matching is not complete measurement-operator equivalence. No fitted time shift." }, "horizontalOperator": "Containing200mcell,nominal10m above model terrain; no spatial blending or point selection by error. All six cases use same physical cell. No height/exposure correction.", "directionOperator": "Use saved U/V directly and FROM=atan2(-U,-V). Source branch omits UTM meridian-convergence rotation; do not rotate twice. Diagnostic adjustments act in projected model axes, so this is the model source convention rather than a rigorously transformed earth-relative field.", "observations": "Reparse retained ECCC native JSON with original numeric tokens, all UTC/local-clock checks, station IDs, missingness and flags. Convert km/h\u00f73.6 and integer1..36 bearings\u00d710; speed0=>zero vector with no directional meaning.", "eligibility": "Same as frozen monthly study: finite nonnegative observed speed and clear wind/general flags; nonzero-speed vector also needs valid bearing. Missing remains missing; no filling. All complete model values must be finite.", "metrics": { "speed": [ "signed model-minus-observed mean", "MAE", "RMSE" ], "vector": "sqrt(mean((Umodel-Uobs)^2+(Vmodel-Vobs)^2)), no division by2; common valid-observation cohort across cases", "direction": "absolute wrapped angular difference on pairs with both speeds>=1m/s;0.5and2m/s sensitivities and denominators retained. Also common cohort where observed and ALL seven model series speeds>=threshold, to avoid ranking different subsets.", "calm": "Report observed speed0 count and model speed distribution/range; no synthetic wind direction for observed calm.", "uncertainty": "Descriptive one-day comparisons; no p-values, confidence intervals or acceptance threshold inferred after errors." }, "additionalReference": { "id": "native-wrf-10m", "source": "work/bc-wrf-wind-june2023/results/native-surface.json", "sourceSha256": "63b080145545ffcac7edc5bce157287f8d6385ac0476367d50e20d69c19c0765", "selection": "Previously frozen nearest native airport point (i33,j84), same24endpointtimestamps. Distinct sampling/operator and1.333km resolution; native WS10 differs from full-profile diagnostic wind.", "nativePoint": { "distance_m": 778.1213867907702, "tile": "x031y081x040y090", "i": 33, "j": 84, "latitude_token": "49.7889", "longitude_token": "-123.1675", "terrain_HGT_rounded_m_MSL_token": "22", "landuse_LU_INDEX_token": "16", "source_line": 81, "source_url": "https://nrs.objectstore.gov.bc.ca/wrfdel/calpuff/3ddat/202306/d06/0308/x031y081x040y090.202306.10x10.d06.m3d" } }, "remainingLimits": [ "Potential upstream WRF station assimilation unknown: consistency diagnostic, not withheld independent validation.", "Actual2023sensor height/exposure/averaging notverified; registry nominal10m and dated metadata limitations retained.", "Pam Rocks about3.9km south of expanded domain; no extrapolation or substituted model point.", "No source-site/elevated-wind or inversion validation, plume transport, chemistry, emissions or health prediction." ], "plannedOutputs": "All expected interval/endpoint timestamps, original tokens and flags, model values/errors, common-cohort summaries, full-day figure, source semantics and coverage report. No selective omission of poor results." }, "extraction": { "protocolSha256": "66b09f6120ce7b6e97f7ccb12ca348cd3f8c5f9417b508979d17a96f9fd8e707", "sourceReview": "source-review.md", "casesExtracted": [ { "case": "original/wrf-interpolation", "recordCount": 1828, "stationValuesExtracted": 720, "staticAtCell": { "ZFACE": [ 0.0, 20.0, 40.0, 80.0, 160.0, 300.0, 600.0, 1000.0, 1500.0, 2200.0, 3000.0 ], "Z0": 0.2218191921710968, "ILANDU": 32, "ELEV": 56.009437561035156, "XLAI": 2.704904556274414 }, "outputSha256": "e761091d59087964939a045c197a318d2274d017f31b042902a79d0ef485c205", "pointIndexSouthFirst": 9565 }, { "case": "original/terrain-5km", "recordCount": 1828, "stationValuesExtracted": 720, "staticAtCell": { "ZFACE": [ 0.0, 20.0, 40.0, 80.0, 160.0, 300.0, 600.0, 1000.0, 1500.0, 2200.0, 3000.0 ], "Z0": 0.2218191921710968, "ILANDU": 32, "ELEV": 56.009437561035156, "XLAI": 2.704904556274414 }, "outputSha256": "6f5a5890874be484c1f7f11d81534d42836257d44ddb743a9fa8013dc939f0fc", "pointIndexSouthFirst": 9565 }, { "case": "original/terrain-10km", "recordCount": 1828, "stationValuesExtracted": 720, "staticAtCell": { "ZFACE": [ 0.0, 20.0, 40.0, 80.0, 160.0, 300.0, 600.0, 1000.0, 1500.0, 2200.0, 3000.0 ], "Z0": 0.2218191921710968, "ILANDU": 32, "ELEV": 56.009437561035156, "XLAI": 2.704904556274414 }, "outputSha256": "f872e3c08e45fca3fafcaa32f73398e0a40d8dd5e6b6343eb89106492761fc09", "pointIndexSouthFirst": 9565 }, { "case": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "recordCount": 1828, "stationValuesExtracted": 720, "staticAtCell": { "ZFACE": [ 0.0, 20.0, 40.0, 80.0, 160.0, 300.0, 600.0, 1000.0, 1500.0, 2200.0, 3000.0 ], "Z0": 0.2218191921710968, "ILANDU": 32, "ELEV": 56.009437561035156, "XLAI": 2.704904556274414 }, "outputSha256": "87fa4e6c19c1a663efe7211a47fd60bd54aff9bf3d6f38ccd62ba7d4ec59eadc", "pointIndexSouthFirst": 29065 }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-5km", "recordCount": 1828, "stationValuesExtracted": 720, "staticAtCell": { "ZFACE": [ 0.0, 20.0, 40.0, 80.0, 160.0, 300.0, 600.0, 1000.0, 1500.0, 2200.0, 3000.0 ], "Z0": 0.2218191921710968, "ILANDU": 32, "ELEV": 56.009437561035156, "XLAI": 2.704904556274414 }, "outputSha256": "a37c6e4d1de051b0ec8a6f2633def1ee38682b9514bb20941f834c897291e2bb", "pointIndexSouthFirst": 29065 }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-10km", "recordCount": 1828, "stationValuesExtracted": 720, "staticAtCell": { "ZFACE": [ 0.0, 20.0, 40.0, 80.0, 160.0, 300.0, 600.0, 1000.0, 1500.0, 2200.0, 3000.0 ], "Z0": 0.2218191921710968, "ILANDU": 32, "ELEV": 56.009437561035156, "XLAI": 2.704904556274414 }, "outputSha256": "8bc1b4c5b5da07d6f95bbcb0c7fc5bda08e74670b4f727e398967bdf46b32002", "pointIndexSouthFirst": 29065 } ], "rows": 168, "all24ExpectedTimesRetainedPerSeries": true, "observationTimes": "UTC June1 09 through June2 08 inclusive", "missingObservationTimes": [], "commonVectorCohort": true, "sharedCellStaticAcrossCases": true, "independentValidation": false, "concentrationPrediction": false }, "sourceSemantics": { "reviewScope": "Read-only static source review; no model execution, model-source edits, control edits, site edits, or observational skill claim.", "configuration": { "PMAP": "UTM", "IPROG": 14, "IWFCOD": 1, "NOOBS": 2, "LSAVE": true, "IFORMO": 1, "IGFMET": 0, "ISTEPPGS": 3600, "NSECDT": 3600, "ABTZ": "UTC-0800", "NSSTA": 0, "NUSTA": 0, "NOWSTA": 0 }, "horizontalSemantics": { "storage": "CALMET final diagnostic model x/y components at cell centres, m/s", "nativeInputConvention": "Meteorological wind-from degrees clockwise from true north; U=-speed*sin(direction), V=-speed*cos(direction).", "nativeUTMRotationApplied": false, "readerRotationBranch": "LLCC OR LPS only, false for PMAP=UTM", "comparisonConvention": "Compute observed U/V directly from true-north wind-from direction using same formula. Do not apply another WRF or UTM rotation to saved fields.", "qualification": "CALMET inserts true-north components into projected UTM x/y operations without UTM meridian-convergence correction. This is the source-defined approximation, not a rigorously transformed earth-relative diagnostic field." }, "temporalSemantics": { "operator": "Linear interpolation of spatially processed native wind components to explicit CALMET interval end. With coincident hourly native records, selects the endpoint state.", "formula": "alpha=(CALMET_interval_end-t1)/ISTEPPGS; Uprog=Uprog1+alpha*(Uprog2-Uprog1); same for V.", "isNativeIntervalAverage": false, "isIntervalStartState": false, "finalDiagnosticQualification": "Thermal/slope calculations can also depend on midpoint solar angle and prognostic temperature history; final field is diagnostic for the interval driven by endpoint native wind.", "timestampNormalization": "End seconds can be 3600 while end YYYYJJJHH equals start YYYYJJJHH. Add seconds before converting to UTC.", "firstTargetUTC": "2023-06-01T09:00:00Z", "lastTargetUTC": "2023-06-02T08:00:00Z" }, "previousCSVLabels": "hour_fixed_PST=0..23 are valid interval-start identifiers. They are misleading if presented as exact point times or matched to near-hour observations at interval start.", "sourceFiles": [ { "path": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "sha256": "fc7fda7cb7e7932f67eb0ce1fb94f1d81a2084063a1dbf797b3270b460b7ee6f", "originalPath": "work/calmet65-local/source/original/CALMET_v6.5.0_L150223/CALMET.FOR", "byteIdenticalToOriginal": true }, { "path": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/map.met", "sha256": "ca044260f1de1558f263ef8d3ea1b0a5dce0aa7992445568904ffe3b9904ab89", "originalPath": "work/calmet65-local/source/original/CALMET_v6.5.0_L150223/MAP.MET", "byteIdenticalToOriginal": true }, { "path": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/gen.met", "sha256": "49ff5338b9a148acde5e2b85305a6e6e764a8c69b831814663f710632f121299", "originalPath": "work/calmet65-local/source/original/CALMET_v6.5.0_L150223/GEN.MET", "byteIdenticalToOriginal": true }, { "path": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/d1.met", "sha256": "dc5d803266e06497c588299ddc507266779adc09fc48167526b9bd534c0ce0fb", "originalPath": "work/calmet65-local/source/original/CALMET_v6.5.0_L150223/D1.MET", "byteIdenticalToOriginal": true }, { "path": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/grid.met", "sha256": "ee835abc4d747c73fcd3196c44ed4caa605ff2727c1d01d20b29ceb69d8e6055", "originalPath": "work/calmet65-local/source/original/CALMET_v6.5.0_L150223/GRID.MET", "byteIdenticalToOriginal": true }, { "path": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/mm4hdo.met", "sha256": "c4d54d3eb7043744dccaac78b7e7650116a6d7921afda9204cf7624b50c4f17d", "originalPath": "work/calmet65-local/source/original/CALMET_v6.5.0_L150223/MM4HDO.MET", "byteIdenticalToOriginal": true }, { "path": "work/bc-wrf-access/pilot/format-review/private-reference/code/calwrf.f", "sha256": "cca879071e9c602cfa957bace0a273e144581edaf8c878e3be01f0bfe835878e" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/analyze.py", "sha256": "ef7d024e8918973ba09f931a6efa1589e3a8cc951f312ad5e92c47e7e3bb47ef" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/wrf-interpolation/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "be5cff439162ad3068807bb5297ff24f07b6dd0da87a7b1cbc96d5dbc1e97930" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/terrain-5km/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "0e614895b605fe38e7817ae0173c33571e5e38244e58497a8fe6e878c7f5330e" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/terrain-10km/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "fb4b7bb338b37d0fbc9dadee911e54d4fbf28f44624d316d051afac42901af90" } ], "evidence": { "projection_flags": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 1850, 1851, 25644, 25650 ] }, "rdmm5_direction_rotation_and_components": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 21674, 21705 ] }, "rdmm5_time_target": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 22330, 22358, 22381, 22386 ] }, "rdmm5_record_times": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 21220, 21240, 21283, 21292, 22007, 22014 ] }, "comp_time_construction": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 3776, 3780, 3828, 3852 ] }, "comp_diagno_call": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 4506, 4513 ] }, "iprog14_rdmm5_to_first_guess": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 5503, 5511, 5550, 5557 ] }, "final_wind_transformations": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 5621, 5629, 5643, 5644, 5721, 5732, 5751, 5763, 6117, 6180 ] }, "lsave_outhr": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 4790, 4811 ] }, "outhr_uv_records": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 13144, 13158 ] }, "wrtr2d_direct_write": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 36865, 36878 ] }, "final_polar_conversion": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 29694, 29702 ] }, "midpoint_solar": { "file": "work/calmet65-local/build/native-650-150223/calmet.for", "lines": [ 3854, 3874 ] }, "calwrf_rotation": { "file": "work/bc-wrf-access/pilot/format-review/private-reference/code/calwrf.f", "lines": [ 438, 458, 679, 719, 2069, 2092 ] }, "previous_start_labels": { "file": "work/buffered-wind-2023/analyze.py", "lines": [ 29, 35, 64, 66 ] } }, "intervals": [ { "interval_index_0": 0, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T00:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T01:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T09:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315200, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315200, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 1, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T01:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T02:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T10:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315201, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315201, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 2, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T02:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T03:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T11:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315202, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315202, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 3, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T03:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T04:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T12:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315203, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315203, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 4, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T04:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T05:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T13:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315204, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315204, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 5, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T05:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T06:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T14:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315205, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315205, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 6, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T06:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T07:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T15:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315206, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315206, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 7, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T07:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T08:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T16:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315207, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315207, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 8, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T08:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T09:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T17:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315208, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315208, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 9, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T09:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T10:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T18:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315209, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315209, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 10, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T10:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T11:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T19:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315210, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315210, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 11, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T11:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T12:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T20:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315211, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315211, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 12, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T12:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T13:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T21:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315212, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315212, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 13, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T13:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T14:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T22:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315213, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315213, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 14, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T14:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T15:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-01T23:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315214, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315214, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 15, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T15:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T16:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T00:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315215, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315215, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 16, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T16:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T17:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T01:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315216, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315216, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 17, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T17:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T18:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T02:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315217, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315217, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 18, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T18:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T19:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T03:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315218, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315218, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 19, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T19:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T20:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T04:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315219, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315219, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 20, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T20:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T21:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T05:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315220, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315220, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 21, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T21:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T22:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T06:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315221, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315221, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 22, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T22:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T23:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T07:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315222, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315222, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 }, { "interval_index_0": 23, "interval_start_fixed_PST": "2023-06-01T23:00:00-08:00", "interval_end_fixed_PST": "2023-06-02T00:00:00-08:00", "native_wind_target_UTC": "2023-06-02T08:00:00Z", "CALMET_begin_YYYYJJJHH": 202315223, "CALMET_begin_seconds": 0, "CALMET_end_YYYYJJJHH": 202315223, "CALMET_end_seconds": 3600 } ] }, "independent": { "candidateHashes": { "paired.json": "13f55562ec3a433e33f58ce0e2727d3efda66ef436b5ecb313be445c84470883", "paired.csv": "7a19bc226545797f5ecc7f503d33bfd827843edcb8a0ff806bff8fc38fd1a466", "summary.json": "f26e85e321056b54684b9848dbef827ea051110c8a6d80549fc2f774c3b63150", "summary.csv": "cf1ff392900190ed82e35b4e368b9661cf68e80659f04038c2e03ea6a65e9f09", "direction.json": "e139b24dba1712f72ce0592cbe99a886dc874dabafb7a05e9ba7b7f9d8c19648", "direction.csv": "429910406d3cd075beb5378f15a1bc202a8b74bd3efc820a4a95667745bb7499", "point-profiles.json": "49e8dc7176e20db42b5b2c0aa771640777b24797a38d80436fe2e99488a4b878", "point-profiles.csv": "98d1374b52026ec04bb678031b27fb5a8504a0392e000d8f25ce275660d5c6aa", "extraction-checks.json": "35179ccf5a966b336a48f961ef2bee54b5bddb82515fa5add3a3db709c8790e3" }, "protocolSha256": "66b09f6120ce7b6e97f7ccb12ca348cd3f8c5f9417b508979d17a96f9fd8e707", "scriptSha256": "5009ea0ae78f00d5d8f27563be0702cc400c0096d850178a73ea514f67e3190a", "independentPhysicalValidation": false, "method": "Independent stdlib streamed Fortran array parser, JSON numeric-token hooks, scalar statistics and trigonometric angular error. No candidate compare.py import/read/execution. Native reference rechecked against original M3D raw fixed-width lines. Independent transverse-Mercator series for geometry.", "counts": { "protocol_hash": 1, "independent_utm_geometry": 2, "station_domain_membership": 2, "frozen_source_hash": 14, "eccc_utc_local_equivalence": 698, "eccc_local_components": 698, "eccc_utc_components": 698, "eccc_unique_time_and_id": 698, "eccc_identity": 698, "eccc_station_coordinates": 698, "all_24_observation_endpoints": 1, "case_containing_cell": 6, "case_shared_cell_centre": 6, "case_cell_offset": 6, "fortran_record_marker": 10968, "calmet_header_period": 6, "calmet_header_timezone": 6, "calmet_header_dimensions": 6, "calmet_header_geometry": 6, "normalized_interval": 4320, "wind_grid_array_length": 4320, "station_wind_finite": 4320, "unique_wind_record": 4320, "all_wind_components_layers_times": 6, "vertical_faces": 6, "all_case_static_identical": 1, "native_wrf_tokens": 24, "native_wrf_raw_record_provenance": 24, "native_wrf_values_and_point": 24, "all_24_native_wrf_endpoints": 1, "candidate_list_length": 100, "candidate_object_keys": 9086, "candidate_numeric_value": 12756, "candidate_exact_value": 41715, "candidate_unchanged_during_review": 9 }, "maximumAbsoluteCandidateNumericDifferences": { "paired_json": 5.684341886080802e-14, "paired_csv": 5.684341886080802e-14, "summary_json": 0, "summary_csv": 0, "direction_json": 1.0658141036401503e-14, "direction_csv": 1.0658141036401503e-14, "point-profiles_json": 0, "point-profiles_csv": 0, "extraction": 0 }, "candidateRowsChecked": 168, "candidateProfileValuesChecked": 4320, "candidateSummaryRowsChecked": 7, "candidateDirectionRowsChecked": 42, "sourceHashes": [ { "path": "work/bc-wrf-access/june-2023-eccc/airport-2023-06-native.json", "sha256": "75c1c04b33bc037089bcea4647cf46d5f693f6e5296cf8e23e25261fad529e94" }, { "path": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/wrf-interpolation/CALMET.DAT", "sha256": "e761091d59087964939a045c197a318d2274d017f31b042902a79d0ef485c205" }, { "path": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/wrf-interpolation/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "4c62e1608cc0939de90015a3e70dc57f91b7e92c255a80e453a1ea33155e1d24" }, { "path": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/terrain-5km/CALMET.DAT", "sha256": "6f5a5890874be484c1f7f11d81534d42836257d44ddb743a9fa8013dc939f0fc" }, { "path": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/terrain-5km/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "71f02d98eaadcda0d66008201c618905c7f4af72aa93f26d61201bea395b0e1b" }, { "path": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/terrain-10km/CALMET.DAT", "sha256": "f872e3c08e45fca3fafcaa32f73398e0a40d8dd5e6b6343eb89106492761fc09" }, { "path": "work/regional-calmet-june2023/runs/terrain-10km/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "368595cb54b48987aa12288a39a1dcb5d7bcd55a7376cf08ce677d7dbfc65b65" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/wrf-interpolation/CALMET.DAT", "sha256": "87fa4e6c19c1a663efe7211a47fd60bd54aff9bf3d6f38ccd62ba7d4ec59eadc" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/wrf-interpolation/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "be5cff439162ad3068807bb5297ff24f07b6dd0da87a7b1cbc96d5dbc1e97930" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/terrain-5km/CALMET.DAT", "sha256": "a37c6e4d1de051b0ec8a6f2633def1ee38682b9514bb20941f834c897291e2bb" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/terrain-5km/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "0e614895b605fe38e7817ae0173c33571e5e38244e58497a8fe6e878c7f5330e" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/terrain-10km/CALMET.DAT", "sha256": "8bc1b4c5b5da07d6f95bbcb0c7fc5bda08e74670b4f727e398967bdf46b32002" }, { "path": "work/buffered-wind-2023/runs/terrain-10km/CALMET.INP", "sha256": "fb4b7bb338b37d0fbc9dadee911e54d4fbf28f44624d316d051afac42901af90" }, { "path": "work/bc-wrf-wind-june2023/results/native-surface.json", "sha256": "63b080145545ffcac7edc5bce157287f8d6385ac0476367d50e20d69c19c0765" }, { "path": "work/bc-wrf-wind-june2023/native/x031y081x040y090.202306.10x10.d06.m3d", "sha256": "a3128a4668c1c965d954067f7f9bf5c4374a012cf6f87a7a345fb9dc54014310" } ], "discrepancies": [], "passed": true }, "summary": [ { "case": "original/wrf-interpolation", "expected_slots": 24, "observations_present": 24, "speed_pairs": 24, "vector_pairs": 24, "obs_mean_speed_ms": 1.712962962962963, "model_mean_speed_ms": 4.013890594348099, "speed_bias_ms": 2.3009276313851363, "speed_mae_ms": 2.410296807850267, "speed_rmse_ms": 2.780226224478539, "vector_rmse_ms": 3.2726819833623084, "reported_calm_pairs": 10, "model_calm_speed_median_ms": 1.0025052532920276, "model_calm_speed_max_ms": 3.6486831317138426 }, { "case": "original/terrain-5km", "expected_slots": 24, "observations_present": 24, "speed_pairs": 24, "vector_pairs": 24, "obs_mean_speed_ms": 1.712962962962963, "model_mean_speed_ms": 4.218188360674524, "speed_bias_ms": 2.5052253977115613, "speed_mae_ms": 2.6186741780903673, "speed_rmse_ms": 3.0098134852028315, "vector_rmse_ms": 3.484913642136324, "reported_calm_pairs": 10, "model_calm_speed_median_ms": 1.1698240219364702, "model_calm_speed_max_ms": 4.5306311027088295 }, { "case": "original/terrain-10km", "expected_slots": 24, "observations_present": 24, "speed_pairs": 24, "vector_pairs": 24, "obs_mean_speed_ms": 1.712962962962963, "model_mean_speed_ms": 4.2811861660058375, "speed_bias_ms": 2.5682232030428747, "speed_mae_ms": 2.6824344863544716, "speed_rmse_ms": 3.085914444440517, "vector_rmse_ms": 3.55684055842939, "reported_calm_pairs": 10, "model_calm_speed_median_ms": 1.2328434640952124, "model_calm_speed_max_ms": 4.7867410325113235 }, { "case": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "expected_slots": 24, "observations_present": 24, "speed_pairs": 24, "vector_pairs": 24, "obs_mean_speed_ms": 1.712962962962963, "model_mean_speed_ms": 4.013890594348099, "speed_bias_ms": 2.3009276313851363, "speed_mae_ms": 2.410296807850267, "speed_rmse_ms": 2.780226224478539, "vector_rmse_ms": 3.2726819833623084, "reported_calm_pairs": 10, "model_calm_speed_median_ms": 1.0025052532920276, "model_calm_speed_max_ms": 3.6486831317138426 }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-5km", "expected_slots": 24, "observations_present": 24, "speed_pairs": 24, "vector_pairs": 24, "obs_mean_speed_ms": 1.712962962962963, "model_mean_speed_ms": 4.218188360674524, "speed_bias_ms": 2.5052253977115613, "speed_mae_ms": 2.6186741780903673, "speed_rmse_ms": 3.0098134852028315, "vector_rmse_ms": 3.484913642136324, "reported_calm_pairs": 10, "model_calm_speed_median_ms": 1.1698240219364702, "model_calm_speed_max_ms": 4.5306311027088295 }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-10km", "expected_slots": 24, "observations_present": 24, "speed_pairs": 24, "vector_pairs": 24, "obs_mean_speed_ms": 1.712962962962963, "model_mean_speed_ms": 4.267573142845438, "speed_bias_ms": 2.5546101798824754, "speed_mae_ms": 2.6688214631940723, "speed_rmse_ms": 3.0695648428253817, "vector_rmse_ms": 3.5410037822091445, "reported_calm_pairs": 10, "model_calm_speed_median_ms": 1.2197332819511835, "model_calm_speed_max_ms": 4.734946436917945 }, { "case": "native-wrf-10m", "expected_slots": 24, "observations_present": 24, "speed_pairs": 24, "vector_pairs": 24, "obs_mean_speed_ms": 1.712962962962963, "model_mean_speed_ms": 4.4375, "speed_bias_ms": 2.7245370370370368, "speed_mae_ms": 2.7819444444444446, "speed_rmse_ms": 3.233983166211841, "vector_rmse_ms": 4.009370315524076, "reported_calm_pairs": 10, "model_calm_speed_median_ms": 1.2999999999999998, "model_calm_speed_max_ms": 3.6 } ], "directionCohorts": [ { "case": "original/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 27.458328291262905, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 27.458328291262905, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 37.767928387821485, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 37.767928387821485, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 27.458328291262905, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 27.458328291262905, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 28.91417856870865, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 28.91417856870865, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 39.33090419348949, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 39.33090419348949, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 28.91417856870865, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 28.91417856870865, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 29.199908066433636, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 29.199908066433636, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 39.63956964522871, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 39.63956964522871, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 29.199908066433636, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "original/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 29.199908066433636, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 27.458328291262905, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 27.458328291262905, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 37.767928387821485, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 37.767928387821485, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 27.458328291262905, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/wrf-interpolation", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 27.458328291262905, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 28.91417856870865, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 28.91417856870865, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 39.33090419348949, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 39.33090419348949, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 28.91417856870865, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-5km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 28.91417856870865, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 29.137034688797485, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 29.137034688797485, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 39.58153268125688, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 39.58153268125688, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 29.137034688797485, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "expanded/terrain-10km", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 29.137034688797485, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "native-wrf-10m", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 35.383333333333326, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "native-wrf-10m", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 1.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 35.383333333333326, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "native-wrf-10m", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 14, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 54.39999999999999, "over90_count": 2, "interval_indices": [ 6, 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "native-wrf-10m", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 0.5, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 13, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 44.86923076923077, "over90_count": 1, "interval_indices": [ 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "native-wrf-10m", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "each_series", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 35.383333333333326, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] }, { "case": "native-wrf-10m", "minimum_both_speeds_ms": 2.0, "cohort": "all_seven_common", "pairs": 12, "mean_absolute_direction_error_deg": 35.383333333333326, "over90_count": 0, "interval_indices": [ 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 ] } ], "figure": { "png": "woodfibre-calmet-observation-check.png", "svg": "woodfibre-calmet-observation-check.svg", "visuallyInspected": true }, "sourceLicensing": { "ECCC": "Environment and Climate Change Canada data; retained provider licence in the methods archive.", "BCWRF": "B.C. public WRF archive; original numerical records identified by URL and hash, not redistributed here.", "code": "Third-party CALMET/CALWRF source is identified by exact version, paths, hashes and line locators; not redistributed in this archive." } }